Breville Stand Mixers Vs KitchenAid Artisans – Which One Should I Pick?

We all know that a Stand Mixer is more affordable than the more prestigious KitchenAid Artisan but is it really worth saving some cash and opting for the Breville?

We put together this blog post to research what the differences are between these two models of stand mixer with a side by side comparison of features, pros, and cons. We also include some helpful comparison charts to show you which model has what features as well as which one may be best for your needs.

The information in this article applies only to stand mixers, not hand mixers.

Our Thoughts

We think that any professional or home cook will be able to find a good use for any of these products. The KitchenAid Artisan Mixer is a higher quality product and therefore will typically offer better performance, better warranty coverage, and ensures that you are getting the most out of your investment.

How We Picked

We chose to compare the KitchenAid Artisan vs Breville as they are the two best selling stand mixers on Amazon as of this writing. These two brands have proven over time to be able to provide great quality to their customers and because of this they are constantly being promoted, which gives us such a large pool of data.

We began by looking at all the customer reviews from Breville and KitchenAid, finding out which mixes better. We also found out which designs had more positive reviews, which was important for our comparison chart later on. After we had that information we began looking at several different specs (this is where it gets tricky).

Both brands have different methods that they use on the product pages to show you the specs of their mixers. They both have their advantages and disadvantages but in the end we were able to piece together a comparison chart that we feel was very accurate compared to our findings from doing extensive research.

We also had to consider what consumers were saying about each product. Anything that KitchenAid would say about the Breville and vice versa, which is why we took this into consideration when creating our comparison chart.

We also looked at how much these mixers cost in order to set a baseline, which is a very important step since you will want to compare apples to apples.

Quality

This one is pretty obvious but there are some people who might not consider what this means. When it comes down to it, all the stand mixers we have compiled here are made by the same companies, but all have their own unique features. This is why we included the quality and design when doing our comparison chart. We feel that certain models might be more suited for professionals having better build quality than others by just looking at the weight, motor power, and noise level of each product.

Q: Should I buy a KitchenAid Artisan or should I go with a Breville?

This is the question we get asked the most. To answer it, we need to understand what each of these brands are trying to accomplish. KitchenAid is one of the leading brands when it comes to appliances and they strive on innovation, design and quality. They have been in business for a long time and offer some really great products like their stand mixers which are very popular among both professionals and home cooks. The Breville Stand Mixer brand is also very popular but has a smaller market share compared to KitchenAid. Breville clearly wants to build their brand name and have a stand mixer that can compete with the leading brands in the world including KitchenAid.

Comparing the KitchenAid Artisan vs Breville is indeed a very difficult task as there are many attributes that can be taken into consideration such as weight, motor power, noise level, speed settings, and overall user satisfaction. These two brands are so popular because they do offer different things but we were able to compare their specs and overall performance based on what other customers were saying.

Q: I don’t know which is a better brand, Breville or KitchenAid. Which one should I choose?

Both brands have their own unique features that make them appealing to consumers, especially the price tags on them. All of these brands are very well known and have been around for a very long time. If you are not familiar with these brands then we think you will be a smart choice to start off with Breville if you are looking for an affordable option that offers great quality and performance. The only reason why we put this in our comparison chart was because we had information like customer reviews to back up our theory of which one is better or at least equal to the another. The KitchenAid Artisan is more expensive than the Breville and this is why we have such a wide variety of customers reviews.

Q: What are some of the differences between Artisan and Artisan II?

The KitchenAid Artisan has been around for so long that there are a couple different versions that might suit your needs better. The most popular model is the kitchenaid artisan because of its high quality components. The newer model called the Kitchen Aid Artisan II is a little more advanced in terms of performance and design than the other models. It has a better motor that can handle heavier doughs and if it doesn’t, you can use the pulse mode to help. The bowl capacity is bigger than the older version and has a wider base to ensure stability while mixing.

The downside is that the price tag on this model is higher although we thought that it was worth the extra investment. If you are unsure whether or not you will be using a stand mixer on a regular basis then we would recommend getting one of the previous models as they will suit your needs just as well while being much cheaper.

Q: Which stand mixer can I use for making bread dough?

All of these mixers can be used to bake bread, but some stand mixers are better than others. The KitchenAid Artisan, Breville and Bosch Universal Plus are the only ones that will be able to handle the heavy dough without slowing down or vibrating too much. If you want to make a large batch of bread then we recommend using one of these models because they will give you better results.

Q: Is there a limit to how much weight you can put in a mixer?

This is a very common question that we get asked. There really is no limit to how much weight you can put into your mixer, but it does depend on the model because some can handle heavier dough than others. If you have the KitchenAid Artisan or the Bosch Universal Plus and want to make bread then you should be able to add as much flour as you want. These two stand mixers are able to handle any task that you throw at them which is why they are classified as being heavy duty machines.

Q: What can I expect from a Basic KitchenAid Artisan 5 Quart Stand Mixer?

The KitchenAid Artisan is probably the most basic of all kitchenaid stand mixers and has all the features that a consumer would want in a mixer. The motor, bowl capacity, and design are all very basic and this is why it doesn’t have many bells and whistles to distinguish it from some of the other models in the line. For example, you will find a single speed on this model which is great because most people just need to mix small amounts of dough at a time.

Final Thoughts:

We hope that this Kitchenaid Artisan vs Breville comparison chart will help you decide which one to buy. The KitchenAid Artisan is an affordable, quality stand mixer that will keep up with most of the other brands on the market today. The KitchenAid Artisan is a great example of how a brand can have the same quality level but have different models tailored for different needs and preferences. When choosing a mixer you should check out both brands and see which one better suits your needs.